Luigi Mangione's New York defense team briefly floated an Extreme Emotional Disturbance defense against his murder charges in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson -- then pulled it back almost immediately.
Today we break down exactly what happened, what that defense actually means under New York law, and why the lawyers may have thought better of it within hours of announcing it—as well as the implications for all this for Mangione’s parallel prosecution taking place in the federal courts.
The Extreme Emotional Disturbance defense is not an acquittal strategy. At best, it reduces a murder conviction to manslaughter. Choosing it also requires the defense to essentially concede that Mangione did the killing, which is a significant tactical problem when you have not yet tested the prosecution's evidence at trial.
The rapid reversal tells us something important: the defense is under real pressure. The evidence connecting Mangione to the Thompson killing is substantial and public. We look at what that evidence is, why an emotional defense likely makes it worse, not better, and what realistic options remain for the defense as the case moves forward.
Join me LIVE right after the open-access show as I break it all down.
All @TheBrancaShow mugs! https://tinyurl.com/k778wj2k
BONUS SHOW STARTS IMMEDIATELY AFTER MAIN SHOW, FOR MEMBERS ONLY! Schedule start time is just a placeholder!
JOIN OUR COMMUNITY! Exclusive Members-only content & perks! Only ~17 cents/day! $5/month!
YouTube: https://tinyurl.com/hn32rfz9
Locals: https://tinyurl.com/yck4w9kf
FOUNDING FATHERS SPEED DIAL: Founding Fathers SPEED DIAL: https://tinyurl.com/3f7pc8nz
I also invite each of YOU to join me in our desperate but worthy mission to save our great nation.
The easiest way to do that? SUBSCRIBE! SUBSCRIBE! SUBSCRIBE!
YouTube: https://tinyurl.com/hn32rfz9
Locals: https://tinyurl.com/yck4w9kf
Episode #M 1364.
NOTE: We mostly ended up covering Bessent's recent speech last week at the Reagan Library.
Yesterday the great and powerful Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent absolutely WRECKED House Democrats during a hearing of the House Ways & Means Committee.
And that was only day after he had done the same to Senate Democrats in a hearing of the Senate Finance committee.
What is best in life, Bessent the Barbarian? To crush your Democrats, see them driven before you, and hear the lamentations of their gender confused!
Trump just shared with America all the winning his administration has already secured for the nation, as well as all the winning coming down the road.
Yesterday was Trump’s 12th publicly aired cabinet meeting, all in his first 14 months in office. This contrasts sharpy with a mere three that Biden held in the same time frame of his administration.
Join me as I break down the second half of this lengthy cabinet meeting and celebrate all the winning.
Trump just shared with America all the winning his administration has already secured for the nation, as well as all the winning coming down the road.
Yesterday was Trump’s 12th publicly aired cabinet meeting, all in his first 14 months in office. This contrasts sharpy with a mere three that Biden held in the same time frame of his administration.
Join me as I break down the first half of this lengthy cabinet meeting and celebrate all the winning (second half will be covered in tomorrow’s members only show.)
Join me LIVE right after the open-access show as I break it all down.
All @TheBrancaShow mugs! https://tinyurl.com/k778wj2k
Today’s LIVE show with Attorney Andrew Branca of Law of Self Defense will focus on a case out of Wyoming that is a great case example of why representing yourself as your own attorney is a bad idea–and also why a superficial understanding of the law can be an extremely dangerous thing.
TODAY ONLY! State-Specific Use-of-Force Law Course, 35% OFF
Today only, get the state-specific use-of-force law course for any state of your choice, at 35% off and FREE SHIPPING on the DVD version.
Click on the link below NOW!
http://lawofselfdefense.com/state
Remember
You carry a gun so you’re hard to kill.
Know the law so you’re hard to convict.
Stay safe!
–Andrew
Attorney Andrew F. Branca
Law of Self Defense LLC
Law of Self Defense Platinum Protection Program
http://lawofselfdefense.com/platinum
This live show covers the Burlington Coat Factory police shooting in North Hollywood CA that occurred this past Thursday, and accidentally killed a 14-year-old girl, as well, the just published interview of one of the Kim Potter jurors.
LAW OF SELF DEFENSE ADVANCED Class
January 8, 2022
VERY LIMITED SEATS!
Covers all 50 states!
Streamed live online using Zoom
http://lawofselfdefense.com/advanced
NOTE: If you would like a comment or question addressed by Attorney Branca, please provide it through member/supporter access at either http://lawofselfdefense.com/ or at http://lawofselfdefense.locals.com/
FREE BOOK! "The Law of Self Defense" Physical book, 200+ pages, we just ask that you cover the S&H: http://lawofselfdefense.com/freebook
FREE 5-ELEMENTS INFOGRAPHIC: Totally free infographic explaining the 5-elements of any claim of self-defense, if you don't understand these 5-elements you cannot have any idea what lawful self-defense consists of, PDF download, zero cost: ...